WASHINGTON, July 29 (DC Times Online) — A proposed change to Social Security’s annual cost-of-living adjustment could do two things at once: slow benefit growth for higher earners and reduce part of the program’s long-term funding shortfall.
The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, a nonpartisan budget group, said in a July 21 analysis that a flat-rate COLA would give all beneficiaries the same dollar increase each year instead of the current percentage-based increase. Using modeling by Karen Smith of the Urban Institute, CRFB said a version set at the 20th percentile of the benefit range and started in 2027 would close about 50% of Social Security’s 75-year shortfall compared with CRFB’s baseline.
What is a flat-rate COLA?
A COLA is the yearly adjustment meant to help Social Security benefits keep up with inflation. Under current law, that increase is applied as a percentage. That means people with larger monthly checks generally get a larger dollar increase.
CRFB’s proposal would change that. Everyone would receive the same dollar amount, with the increase tied to the COLA received by a beneficiary around the 20th percentile of the benefit range. In practice, that would put a cap on how large the annual increase could be, while also setting a floor so lower-benefit retirees would not be pushed below that amount.
Why does CRFB say it matters?
CRFB says the idea is relatively progressive because it slows benefit growth most for people with the highest lifetime earnings and retirement income. The group said a 20th-percentile flat-rate COLA would delay insolvency of Social Security’s main trust funds by two years.
The organization also said that, if paired with other changes such as an employer compensation tax proposal, the flat-rate COLA could help keep the combined trust funds solvent for 75 years or nearly that long.
How would it affect different retirees?
The impact would not be the same for everyone. Under the 20th-percentile version, CRFB said the bottom fifth of lifetime earners would see projected benefits in 2065 fall by 3%, while the top fifth would see benefits fall by 19%.
Under the 30th-percentile version, CRFB said the bottom fifth would see a 1% increase and the top fifth would see a 17% decrease.
CRFB also said both the 20th- and 30th-percentile designs would increase benefits for the lowest quintile by 13% to 14% compared with a payable-benefits scenario.
Where did the idea come from?
CRFB said the basic concept is not new. The group pointed to a 1987 proposal from then-Rep. Tim Penny and said its retrospective estimate found that if Congress had adopted a flat-rate COLA then, the policy would have kept Social Security solvent through 2071.
Is this a law now?
No. The flat-rate COLA is a proposal, not an enacted change. It would require action by Congress before it could affect benefits.
For now, the debate is about how to balance three goals that often conflict: keeping Social Security affordable, protecting lower-income retirees, and limiting cuts to benefits for people who paid more into the system over their working lives.
