Skip to content

Business and FinanceUnited States4 min read

DEI Consultant Resigns from Cracker Barrel Board After Shareholder Vote

DEI consultant Gilbert Dávila has resigned from Cracker Barrel's board after a contentious shareholder vote, reducing the board to nine directors. This follows a heated proxy fight and criticism against his DEI background and company performance.

Share

Topics

Cracker Barrel board member Gilbert Dávila resigns after heated proxy fight over DEI role

Gilbert Dávila, a DEI consultant and Cracker Barrel board member since 2020, resigned Nov. 20, 2025, after a contentious shareholder vote and proxy fight led by activist investor Sardar Biglari, reducing the board from ten to nine directors.

  • Board change: Dávila’s resignation leaves Cracker Barrel with nine directors instead of ten.
  • Catalyst: An aggressive proxy campaign by Sardar Biglari and negative guidance from proxy advisers influenced the outcome.
  • Focus: Critics tied Dávila’s DEI background and compensation committee role to broader concerns about the company’s rebrand and performance.

Background: Dávila’s role and the company’s troubles

Gilbert Dávila joined the Cracker Barrel board in 2020 and served as chair of the board’s Compensation Committee, helping shape pay and strategic planning decisions, according to company and media reports including DEI consultant resigns Cracker Barrel board after heated proxy fight and Cracker Barrel shareholders show strong support.

Dávila is also known for DEI consulting and earlier marketing roles at companies such as Disney and Sears, a background that became a focal point for critics after a controversial rebrand that drew backlash from customers and commentators (Cracker Barrel’s rebrand flopped and some think DEI is to blame).

The proxy fight and shareholder vote

The resignation follows an aggressive campaign led by activist investor Sardar Biglari, who publicly criticized the board and management for weak financial results, failed acquisitions and a rebrand he called out-of-touch. Coverage of Biglari’s push is available via Fox Business and reporting at Restaurant Business Online.

At the annual meeting shareholders elected nine of ten director nominees — all but Dávila — and supported other company proposals, including executive compensation plans and bylaw amendments, according to preliminary results released by the company via PR Newswire and summaries at IndexBox. After the vote, Dávila stepped down and the board was reduced to nine members.

Proxy advisory firms weigh in

Two major proxy advisory firms, ISS and Glass Lewis, recommended voting against Dávila, citing concerns about leadership and the company’s direction; Glass Lewis also recommended voting against Jody Bilney, chair of the nominating and governance committee (Fox Business; IndexBox).

Those recommendations likely influenced voting patterns. Notably, proxy reports did not call for removal of CEO Julie Felss Masino, who was retained by shareholders (Food Manufacturing).

Controversy over DEI and the rebrand

Dávila’s DEI work became a lightning rod in public debate about the rebrand. Conservative critics and some customers blamed DEI initiatives for moving the brand away from its traditional image — a line of critique amplified in reporting at HR Brew. The controversy was further heightened by an EEOC complaint filed earlier in the year by the conservative legal group America First Legal, as covered in the same reporting.

“We thank Gilbert Dávila for his five years of service and his work on compensation policies and strategic planning,” the board said in a statement when announcing the resignation.

Company response and board statement

Cracker Barrel issued a statement thanking Dávila for his service and saying the company remains focused on creating shareholder value while preserving the brand’s heritage and core values (Fox Business; PR Newswire).

Why the change matters beyond Cracker Barrel

This episode illustrates how investor activism and cultural debates over DEI can converge in ways that reshape corporate governance quickly. Activists use proxy fights to press for leadership changes when companies face customer backlash or weak performance — a dynamic visible in reporting at IndexBox.

Implications for Washington, D.C.

Economic impact: Institutional investors, municipal pension funds and policy-focused groups in D.C. watch proxy fights closely; a high-profile board change at a national retailer can influence voting strategies and pension fund engagement (Fox Business).

Political consequences: The resignation feeds national debates on DEI and could prompt congressional or regulatory attention — particularly given the EEOC complaint tied to the case (HR Brew).

Social effects: D.C. audiences of federal employees, policy advocates and communities may see this episode as a case study in how employers balance brand identity with inclusion efforts.

Cultural relevance: The dispute highlights tension between corporate modernization and stakeholders prioritizing traditional branding, with implications for public perception and political narratives.

Practical applications: Institutional investors and public affairs professionals in the Washington area should review proxy voting policies and communications strategies when rebrands touch sensitive cultural topics (PR Newswire).

Reporting sources and further reading

Share

Topics

Joel Patterson

Joel Patterson is a senior business and finance analyst for Times Media Service, based in the Washington bureau. Patterson covers markets, companies, personal finance and economic policy, along with transportation and its financial and economic impacts. Patterson holds a master's degree in finance and grew up in Newcastle upon Tyne, England.

Write to Joel